Skip to content

Lamento

Musica Antiqua Köln; Magdalena Kozena


This is an interesting program, for it spans different stylistic periods.

Among my favorite works on the CD is a cantata by Francesco Conti, which J.S. Bach evidently had copied and performed in Cöthen. The long fourth movement aria is well done, but the solo violin line that keeps returning almost gets old by the movement’s end. MAK performs BWV 170 too on the recording, with their usual tell-tale faster than we’re used to tempos. I like it, though. The works by later Bachs I felt less inclined to listen to a second time. I have spent the most time listening to the opening track, Ach dass ich Wassers g’nug hätte from Johann Christoph Bach, part of the Alt-Bach Archiv. This has been recorded by MAK earlier, and interesting of course is listening to the concertante violin line. Here Goebel plays with vibrato in ways that his earlier recording didn’t dare try. I am not sure I like the new style with vibrato, nor do I think it is particularly historically accurate? Yet, despite these details, and the fine contributions from Kozena, it’s so easy to listen to.

November 2026: Recorded at the Malancthon-Kirche in Cologne, it doesn’t feature the best sound to my comparisons of earlier MAK recordings made at the German radio recording studio. What’s lacking is the close, transparent access to the individual performers in the ensemble, the solo violin not included.

On the vibrato front, the Alleluja that closes Conti’s cantata, Languet anima mea, features technically assured singing from Kožená with a beautiful application of vibrato, but as readers will no doubt recognize, I question the use of vibrato like this, as continually applied by singers. It comes back in the next track (track 7), with the opening of Bach’s Vergnügte Ruh from BWV 170. If vibrato bothers you, this album may disappoint.

To its credit, Kožená has a particular timbre to her voice that is accompanied here with confidence. We can hear it in the cantata by Johann Christoph Friedrich Bach, Die Amerkianerin, HW18/3. Her voice in the highest register is thin and delicate, but at the lower end it portrays body and weight.

After living with this album for twenty years, I don’t often return to it.

Fans of Biber

Reader Guestbook

How do you listen? (choose any)
What do you follow here? (choose any)

Who may see this?

What you send travels over an encrypted (HTTPS) connection and is stored encrypted on my own server. I do not sell it or share it. Public entries appear only after I approve them, and I can remove yours on request. How your information is handled.