Skip to content

Buying CDs in France


Melomania Music Store

While I recently visited France, I once again took it upon myself to shop for some music, something I’ve always enjoyed doing. I cannot help the fact that I’m old fashioned, and like thumbing through the stacks of CDs in a record store. (I’m not that old, of course, and have no recollection of looking through vinyl albums, although cassettes do seem somewhat familiar.) The American shops I used to find in large cities are almost no longer around, and this time, I wondered if the extinction wasn’t soon to come to places like France. Last year I found one of the last indie shops in London; in France, I remembered an excellent experience at a FNAC. This time around, my “old” FNAC store at the Opéra near Bastille was gone, in its place, a ClubMed gym.

Hmm… Another FNAC store showed me only electronics and books, but no music. DVDs are still in vogue, along with the rarity of Blu Ray.

It turns out I found a place call Chaumière online, but it had been “consumed” by another store, called Melomania. It was nice and quiet, and a very nice, clean space. They used the most curious way to organize CDs that I’ve seen, but aside from not knowing exactly which way to follow the alphabet, I did find some values – at used prices. Since the CDs were wrapped, I’m not sure if they were in fact used or simply discounted.

(I should note that I’ve also eaten at a restaurant in Georgetown (DC) called La Chaumière. Same name. So, that was it for Paris. The other FNAC I’d been to was closed the day I visited, so it wasn’t until Lyon that I visited both a Virgin Megastore and a FNAC.

The FNAC was superior in every way; it was more like what some stores we have in the US, with some small electronics and cameras for sale; iPads, an Apple “Store within a Store,” and music, movies, video games, and books. The difference is, the classical section doesn’t stink. They had some good values at $7, but I opted to just concentrate on new or unusual items.

The Megastore in Lyon I am guessing has 3 weeks max left. Plenty of traffic, but half their bottom floor had the goods ripped out, as if they were going belly-up. No signage indicated it. The classical section stunk; the prices weren’t discounted as they had been at FNAC.

So, needless to say, the likelihood that in a few years you can go into a store and buy music on physical media really is making its way around the world in a “probably ain’t gonna happen” type of way. The whole experience had mixed results for me.

Good:

  • I saw a lot of CDs I already have purchased via online means (like Amazon) or digitally (iTunes).
  • I didn’t notice a lot of stuff that I couldn’t buy electronically.
  • CDs are a good value opposite MP3s; they may cost more, but they come with a built-in backup and are of higher quality.
  • I like browsing with physical media.
  • There’s more stuff for sale online that we can reasonably fit into stores.

Bad:

  • The CD format is dated and has been superseded by SuperAudioCD (and others).
  • The better formats never caught on.
  • No physical browsing online.
  • No assured means for acquiring CD-quality or better electronically – making purchases in compressed formats “compromises.”

In this trip at the Melomania store had a clerk that was helping a customer find what they needed; as did my trip in London last year around the same time. That’s sorely what we’ll be missing out the most – knowledgable staff who can give personal recommendations. Oh well, it’s still fun for as long as it lasts. Apple has an excellent opportunity to make this better…

  • better organization of what’s for sale and better search;
  • high-quality downloads (24 bit, 96Khz would be adequate for me);
  • smart/intelligent suggestions,
  • better integration of “art” and digital booklets (the PDF booklets especially are sorely under-cooked).

If it’s not Apple – then anyone – step up. But when buying from Amazon, Linn, Passionato, and iTunes – since I’m on a Mac and use iOS devices – the all Apple experience works better in some ways… integrated installation across devices, etc. is nice.

Fans of Biber

Reader Guestbook

How do you listen? (choose any)
What do you follow here? (choose any)

Who may see this?

What you send travels over an encrypted (HTTPS) connection and is stored encrypted on my own server. I do not sell it or share it. Public entries appear only after I approve them, and I can remove yours on request. How your information is handled.