Jean Rondeau records concertos by Johann Sebastian Bach and his sons for Erato.
Pieces on Dynastie:
- Concerto in D minor, BWV 1052 (J.S. Bach)
- Concerto in F minor, attributed to Johann Christian Bach (or CPE Bach)
- Lamento from the Sonata in G major, FK 7 (W.F. Bach, orchestrated by Rondeau)
- Concerto in F minor, BWV 1056 (J.S. Bach)
- Concerto in D minor, Wq 23 (C.P.E. Bach)
There is a story to be told here, and it has been told to be sure, about Bach’s genesis of the harpsichord concerto, and with it the keyboard concerto. (To be fair, Handel had composed concertos for the organ with orchestra.) Put ourselves in Leipzig, among the townsfolk and students who frequented Zimmermann’s Coffee House sometime in the 1730s, and we might have heard some of what’s on this disc. But there are a lot of recordings of Bach’s keyboard concertos. That story isn’t the one really told here.
Dynastie features two of father Bach’s concertos, BWV 1052 and 1056. Both were very likely arrangements of earlier pieces for violin or oboe. We can’t know precisely why they were rewritten; it might simply have been Bach’s need to lead the ensemble from his own instrument as virtuoso. That isn’t the story here either. The story is what Bach’s offspring did with the genre.
Looking at the Bachs as a “family dynasty” is an interesting approach for a concert, and I think it works for a recording too. We might imagine the sons at those sessions, playing along in their father’s versions for two, three, and four keyboards. By the time they died, the keyboard concerto had firmly taken off “as a thing.” These pieces may never have lived together as they do on this recording, heard all at once by the folks responsible for writing them. Comparing them is interesting for the modern listener, but they are also good enough to be savored on their own. Bachs of any generation wrote good music.
Rondeau’s playing is clean and crisp, unlike his wild hairstyle (captured on the cover). His colleagues form a very small chamber ensemble, one player to a part, with bassoon added to the continuo for the galant pieces. For the J.S. Bach concertos that fits the music, and it keeps in check the balance problem posed by the timbre and output of a harpsichord. The double bass has enough voice, in BWV 1052 for instance, to give the sound good balance.
My favorite recording of BWV 1052 is Fabio Biondi’s arrangement with Europa Galante; his musicality in the solo violin is remarkably fancy. Rondeau, on the instrument the score asks for, might be a close second. He doesn’t take on Biondi’s fanciful expressivity, but his solo part is so easily heard in the mix. The outer-movement tempi feel “pretty fast,” and to my ears they are perfect. The sound of the ensemble is good too, and here I’m paying special attention to stereo separation.
Rondeau is known for playing fast and furious, but the faster movements elsewhere on the disc shy away from going full-tilt. Each choice seems made to let the main themes shine. When he plays by himself, it all works; there is an intricacy, after all, to the notes Bach employs to project the harpsichord.
The gem of the recording, however, is the concerto in F minor. It’s a really fun, dramatic piece. Its style is far removed from Johann Sebastian’s pen, yet it carries such quality that you’re not surprised to learn it was composed by a Bach. Which Bach is a muddle. This recording lists Johann Christian; another, by Il Giardino Armonico under Giovanni Antonini, lists CPE; and the manuscript tradition is tangled enough that Wilhelm Friedemann has been proposed as well. It’s no matter. The drama is not unrelated to the Vivaldian vein that traces easily back to BWV 1052. The opening theme is simple, a call to attention; it’s the intricate writing for keyboard alone that reveals a newer artistic voice, one ready for longer melody and less reliance on counterpoint. The stylistic gap between father and sons is stark in spots, and we might think the sons had a preference for minor keys. This piece, I’ll dare say, is my favorite on the disc. It lacks the better ideas of the CPE concerto, but it speaks to my emotions.
Against Il Giardino Armonico there is less dynamic contrast in Rondeau’s account, as there was against Biondi in BWV 1052. It’s not really a trade-off, because the benefit is the clarity of a small ensemble. Adding bassoon to the continuo is a brilliant touch that adds flavor to the ensemble’s sound. IGA takes the third movement faster and far more frantically, and I think that works. Rondeau’s slower tempo isn’t a negative; it’s a different take, and it lets the ornamented phrase endings stand out.
While slow movements are not my favorites, they seem to be where Rondeau shows the most creative spirit. The Lamento is his own orchestration of the slow movement from Wilhelm Friedemann’s Sonata in G major, FK 7. Whether through his playing or his direction, there are enough pauses, rubato, and shifts between leanness and fullness in the orchestral sound to know these musicians have a real voice. The piece’s success rests more with the ensemble than with the keyboard player, and Sophie Gent makes a nice contribution on first violin. It also makes me ask what the more appropriate instrument would be. The dynamic twists can’t be echoed by a harpsichord the way they could be on a fortepiano, and I’d be curious to hear the piece that way.
The second J.S. Bach concerto, BWV 1056, is not driven as hard as the first. As with the third movement of the F minor concerto, the tempo allows high precision at turns of phrase where a lot of fast notes come together. It also exposes phrasing by Rondeau that is lost in recordings taking a faster tempo overall. Still, in the finale I’d have liked the tempo pushed harder.
The Largo is a piece I know very well, and the balance seems off to me. The harpsichord is very loud compared to the pizzicato strings, and the lead melody comes across more quietly than the left-hand bass. Is it the coupled keyboard playing the bass line while a single-string configuration is used for the melody on the other keyboard? Or is it something to do with ensemble/keyboard balance? I will continue to audition this track on different equipment. For this review, I listened critically on headphones.
The CPE concerto, Wq 23, is another gem. The opening is another place where Rondeau holds back (I have an alternative recording I like that pushes harder on tempo), but I have little complaint. These musicians seem wiser in their choices once the harpsichord takes the main theme by itself, and the balance works better once Rondeau’s solo takes over. The opening theme would have made J.S. Bach proud. I keep listening to more music by CPE Bach and he’s growing on me; he was Bach’s most gifted composer-son. Compared with the Collegium Aureum under Gustav Leonhardt, I hear the benefit of a larger ensemble, but I like Rondeau’s interpretation many times over better.
Conclusion
I’m having a difficult time putting my finger on Rondeau, to characterize his style. Part of his flavor as an instrumentalist is revealed when watching him perform. He doesn’t “overdo” anything to any great degree. He’s smart, making a lot of wise decisions about how to present the music without adopting any particular manner at the keyboard. For that, we have to look, perhaps, at his hair and beard. There’s more “manner” coming from the ensemble than from Rondeau. It’s not a criticism that he’s a less “dynamic” player than Antonini and Biondi, the two musicians I’ve compared him to here.
Musicianship all around is very high. Setting aside my preferences for tempo, the recording is nearly flawless, with the balance in the Largo of BWV 1056 the one curiosity.
My one real criticism is the string forces. In the J.S. Bach pieces the lean, one-to-a-part ensemble is appropriate; nothing is lacking. But in the music of Bach’s sons, all of it really, the orchestra is too lean. Dynamics are no longer niceties; they are required. The playing is well done. I just wanted more sound and more depth. It was the sons’ writing for a more dynamic orchestra, and perhaps the expectations attached to their own concertos for solo harpsichord, that differentiated them from their father, and not exploring that more fully loses sight of an apt comparison. I’ve heard the JC and CPE concertos with larger ensembles (and faster tempi), and while I think Rondeau gets the tempos right, I can’t help but appreciate what a larger ensemble does for inciting frissons of drama. There is a good rationale for the choice, since holding ensemble size and keyboard constant allows comparisons using the same tools. But I believe the sons’ pieces would have been helped by a slightly larger string group.
What the album does very well is show off the similarities and differences among the Bach clan’s male keyboard composers. All the Bachs represented succeeded at writing dynamic, energizing music with interesting themes. The story, then, is one of a father who, despite looking backward for so much of his career, couldn’t help becoming an innovator, and of sons who continued his tradition by mixing what was good from the “old” examples with new stylistic conventions, elongating phrases, and developing themes in continually interesting ways.
I’m not sure that story is told well enough with so few examples. Here’s hoping for commercial success, and a Dynastie II, III, and IV that follow the same formula.
